Diekan wrote :
"Considering this ISN'T Japan or Europe that argument isn't valid. Europeans and the Japanese do NOT drive as much as we do. Their cities are much more compact (and countries much smaller), thus they depend a great deal more on both public transportation and bicycling than we do / can. The average US citizen lives what? 20 to 40 minutes from their job? The US is much more "spread out" than most other countries. Thus, we have a legit dependancy on our vehicles... we don't just use them "for fun." 5 dollars a gallon for gas doesn't have near the effect on a person living in Tokyo as does 2 dollars a gallon for someone living in Columbus, Ohio. If you can't see that then you need glasses."
How the hell can anyone buy into this fucked up kind of argument? The USA is the LARGEST user of gas in the world. They are the largest user because the price of gas is so low. Saying that because Japan and European cities are closer together means that they use more public transportation is ridiculous. They use public transit, like major US cities, because parking and gas costs are so high. The fact that Americans have chosen to live so far from work is their own fault. In a larger, older city the commute times are just as bad, if not worse than in a spread out North American city. More people in a similar sized area = more traffic messes for public transit.
If the US taxed gas at the same rate as the next lowest country (in this case Canada) the cost would increase by approximately 30%. If that was the case I bet that the US would begin to understand the concept that you don't have to drive everywhere with only one person per car.
And before you can complain that US cities are more spread out because they have room, last I heard Canada has far more than the US does. Sure the older cities in Europe and Japan are more crowded, however gas prices are a NATIONAL level of taxation, not a city based price.
The US relies on foreign oil to run its business like everyone else does. They pay the same price that everyone else does for this oil. If the market says prices are up 50% get used to it, we all have to pay a hell of a lot more than we used to.
It is only because the US does not tax gas as highly as other countries that the entire "entitlement" mentality exists today. If gas cost $3+ per gallon for the last 20 years I can guarantee that people would not be living in suburbs and buying a car for every family member and saying that they need them. Instead, like most major cities in the world, the inner city would not have rotted and had everyone move out and away from all of the slums that a screwed up social welfare system helped to create with ghetto's and projects.