Evermore wrote:ClakarEQ wrote:“A well regulated militia, being necessary to the security of a free state, the right of the people to keep and bear arms, shall not be infringed.”
You can IMO easily say the military IS the militia and only THOSE have the right to bear arms. You see it doesn't say civilian, or common person, layperson, etc. It is very specific to militia and depending on how you spin it, militia can in fact be our armed services, not you or me, only them.
I dont think your military is the militia statement holds water. The very nature of a militia is that it is comprised of ordinary citizens, not professonal soldiers.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Militia
I checked dictionary.com for the real deal, wiki is in the process of being devalued IMO anyway, too much oppertunism there (not saying is has no value though, I use it frequently for reference).
You can easily spin even the wiki to either side of the argument though.
Wikipedia.org wrote:The term militia is commonly used today to refer to a military force composed of ordinary[1] citizens to provide . . . ."
The definition of "Force" in the cotext used is
Dictionary.com wrote:any body of persons combined for joint action
and this in turn is not the "person" or "individual" at all, this is combined "unit", e.g. an organization. So then "law" can propose this question, what organization are civilian gun owners part of because accroding to the interrupted law, this is required for gun ownership.
Tuggan wrote:you honestly believe they would have taken the time and made it 2nd only to freedom of speech (etc.), to say that the military has the right to use weapons?
spun response: You can't honestly believe the 2nd was designed to implement an uncontrolled unorganized armed civilian populace, do you?
Again though, I'm just devil's advocating this stuff, I'm semi-nuetral on this, it is more the point of awarness because for me, some of what I read was new info, and also to show how easy this "right" can be spun against what some feel, is the very purpose is was written for in the first place.