namelesstavern.net

Chester screams too much. to the point he had to have an operation to remove palyps.

It's true he does scream a lot. But he is the best screamer I've ever heard.

I actually don't mind Chester

I wouldn't pay money to see him live tho.


greatest rock vocalist of all time is probably Freddie Mercury tho. definitely the most versatile

Tikker wrote:

Drem wrote:i think a lot of singers could take vocal lessons from him. he had a lot of energy, originality, attitude, range, and diversity

you're kidding right?

nope, not at all. can you guys even say anything bad about Cobain? other than he was mind-numbingly famous and you don't like him because 50,000,000 other people like him too and he's the poster child for a sad depressed musician? because i can look past all that and listen to his demo and home recordings and some amazing live work (even unplugged was pretty good) and walk away totally satisfied. he fit his style of music extremely well. and in case you can't tell, i'm just comparing him to his contemporaries. i can't think of any better rock vocalist in the early '90s that was still putting out important records

if you're comparing him to a singer like freddie mercury then that's retarded because they're not even similar at all, other than they both sang in bands. let's compare bach to bartok next

there isn't a best rock vocalist, because everyone listens to different kinds of rock. i'll never give freddie mercury the kind of credit you think he deserves because Queen actually makes me laugh IRL when i hear it. it just sounds so transsexual and lame. and i'm sure you feel the same about Nirvana

since you guys posted a screamer, tho, i think my favorite metal or hard rock or whatever vocalist is Jay Frechette from Cave In

I listen to Nirvana quite a bit and like it.

I just don't give him anywhere near that level of credit as you do. I don't find him that talented as a vocalist.

Drem wrote:nope, not at all. can you guys even say anything bad about Cobain?

cobain was like dylan, to a certain extent

highly influential, had some great songs, but not a good vocalist by any stretch

yeah we get it, you were 9-10 when you fell in love with nirvana, and he's your favourite

but he's not a great vocalist, get over it

well if you are going to be strict rock and roll

i would say roy orbison hands down

elvis presley hasnt been mentioned

annie lennox

ani defranco

urgh i was going to make an argument about cobain

but then i would be breaking my self-imposed moratorium on arguing matters of taste in this thread

so i erased it

Well, you can argue actual singing ability without delving into taste.

Freddy Mercury was the best vocalist ever.

Tikker wrote:

Drem wrote:nope, not at all. can you guys even say anything bad about Cobain?

cobain was like dylan, to a certain extent

highly influential, had some great songs, but not a good vocalist by any stretch

yeah we get it, you were 9-10 when you fell in love with nirvana, and he's your favourite

but he's not a great vocalist, get over it

and here's you sounding like an arrogant prick

i almost wrote "before you assume that i have posters of kurt cobain, every album, and know how to play the power chords to every single song...." but i didn't actually think you'd try to draw that stereotype

kurt cobain? my favorite since i fell in love with nirvana? hahahaha. i own unplugged. my love is truly undying

we just think different. get over it. dylan, to me, is a lot more exciting than freddie mercury. dylan's first two records make me feel weird and uncomfortable. it's like woody guthrie v2.0. and queen makes me actually laugh IRL. i just can't take it seriously

imo Dylan cant sing for shit. However he is one of the top songwriters and arrangers ever.

btw there are 2 issues with a "best vocalist" thing

1. great singers tend to get discounted cause they only perform in 1 style.
2. this is all personal preference.

Evermore wrote:2. this is all personal preference.

welcome to why i'm not arguing anything in this thread

(and imo why no one else should be)

to take a right turn I been listening more and more to Shadows Fall Brian Fair owns.

Naethyn wrote:It's true he does scream a lot. But he is the best screamer I've ever heard.

Really....

Evermore wrote:to take a right turn I been listening more and more to Shadows Fall Brian Fair owns.

Massachusetts Metal Bands <3

I've met Brian a bunch of times at the Palladium in Worcester. "Hometown" shows are awesome.

Freddie Mercury
Geddy Lee
Layne Staley
Bono
Steve Perry

My 5 current favs:
Freddie Mercury
Robert Plant
Ann Wilson
Ed Sloan
Amy Lee

Iccarra wrote:My 5 current favs:
Freddie Mercury
Robert Plant
Ann Wilson
Ed Sloan
Amy Lee

I really like Amy Lee until I heard her live..

jeje, studio magic at it's best with her

Tikker wrote:

Drem wrote:nope, not at all. can you guys even say anything bad about Cobain?

cobain was like dylan, to a certain extent

highly influential, had some great songs, but not a good vocalist by any stretch

yeah we get it, you were 9-10 when you fell in love with nirvana, and he's your favourite

but he's not a great vocalist, get over it

Dylan was TERRIBLE... who ever let him near a mic should have been shot. Music business guru, yes. Great singer? Not even close.

Anyone mention Chris Cornel yet?

Diekan wrote:

Tikker wrote:

Drem wrote:nope, not at all. can you guys even say anything bad about Cobain?

cobain was like dylan, to a certain extent

highly influential, had some great songs, but not a good vocalist by any stretch

yeah we get it, you were 9-10 when you fell in love with nirvana, and he's your favourite

but he's not a great vocalist, get over it

Dylan was TERRIBLE... who ever let him near a mic should have been shot. Music business guru, yes. Great singer? Not even close.

Anyone mention Chris Cornel yet?

Lol of course. Brinstar is on the board...

Drem wrote:
we just think different. get over it. dylan, to me, is a lot more exciting than freddie mercury. dylan's first two records make me feel weird and uncomfortable. it's like woody guthrie v2.0. and queen makes me actually laugh IRL. i just can't take it seriously

I think the difference is that I know what the thread is about....

Freddie Mercury
Axl Rose (AFD-era)

Tikker wrote:

Drem wrote:
we just think different. get over it. dylan, to me, is a lot more exciting than freddie mercury. dylan's first two records make me feel weird and uncomfortable. it's like woody guthrie v2.0. and queen makes me actually laugh IRL. i just can't take it seriously

I think the difference is that I know what the thread is about....

the difference is your interpretation of a good singer is based on grade-school standards for singing "properly" and anything outside that norm "sucks"