by ClakarEQ » Thu Sep 28, 2006 9:14 am
My kids are 5 and 8, both boys
Regarding parents being good vs bad over time and proof, I have none. This is my observation of the environment around me.
Part of my comments were to also make the analogy of how cable tv is "policed", the internet is not. Knowing there is law in place over a medium such as cable tv, radio, etc. It makes perfect sense for there to be law over the internet as this will become the prefered source/medium for media outlets.
I'm not so worried about the direct interaction, control, whatever you want to call it over MY kids when they are under MY eye. Perhaps this is my "hang-up" and lack of faith for my fellow parent caused from my observations.
Someone posted about it being asinine that government take over parenting. Yeah I agree with this but you realize this is the case today. There are law's right now over parents and kids and such. It was more of what type of controls does the government plan to put in place over the internet to protect its "children". This is the only space left that isn't policed, all other forms of media outlets (within reason and available to common joe folks) are policed by the FCC.
DA on
Why shouldn't the government police / monitor the internet when all other forms of media are.
Why do people assume they know what is best for themselves, this is not always the case and who should be "correcting" these "knowing" people? Our society is obese because folks DO NOT know or DO NOT care what is best for themselves. Using obeseity as the example here, not picking on fat folks.
DA off
This thread in a sense is somewhat futile. IMHO the internet will in fact be policed by our government whether I like it or not. I was curious to see how others fealt about my opinion. My thought process comes from my kids and the ease and the growing ability of unfetered data access.
Here is one of those "when I was a kid" examples LOL
When I was a kid and was getting upto speed on the birds and bees, I looked up words like intercourse, vagina, etc etc. I was curious, I wanted to know all there was to know. Reading this text seemed like science and bilogy to me. Healthy knowledge gain IMHO.
Today a kid is very unlikely to go to a library and look this stuff up. I would sooner see the kid pull a google search off his cell phone, or a google search at the library, friends house, etc.
a bit of rambling here another real world example
My 8 year old is a great speller, not a good writer but reads and spells very good. The family is eating dinner and e-bay comes up in the converstation as my wife bought a halloween thing off e-bay, save some bucks, etc. This isn't a new topic, e-bay has come up before. However my boy had the knowledge gained from the dinner table e-bay chatter over time, to go to e-bay and do some searching for star wars toys. Harmless enough, e-bay wasn't blocked by the filters I put in so when my boy said, they had some cool star wars toys on e-bay, let me show you. I was happy and sad at the same time. I was like, wow, he picked this up on his own, cool, hmm but wait, he put two and two together and just determine in that moment that at least for him e-bay was a source of data, to him this data was starwars as this was his topic, however that may not be his or his friends topic in the future.
I hope you guys are following me here.
I don't want a police state. I don't want more conservatism.
A workable solution that came up at work, during lunch we were talking about this. What if the government actually did something for the people, you know since they've not done a damn thing for the people in my liftime thus far, the government should provide "policed" internet access for "free". Those that want comcast, wow, whatever, you do that, for those that want policied internet, hookup with .gov. This seems like a good balance but I never see this coming to reality as I believe the government will do anything it can to force more monitoring on us as a whole.